Modern barn wood paneling (also known as faux or engineered barnwood) and authentic reclaimed wood both deliver a rustic farmhouse aesthetic. They differ significantly in cost, construction, materials, availability, installation, and upkeep. Let’s see how all this rolls out.

Modern Barn Wood Paneling

Modern barn wood paneling is manufactured from real pinewood with a unique process to simulate old, reclaimed wood. Its advantages over old wood are many, including:

  • Origin: Newly manufactured from sustainable pine or other fresh timber.
  • Character & Consistency: Artificially distressed and textured via specialized mechanical and staining processes to replicate the look of aged wood with high uniformity in width (frequently 6″ or 8″) and thickness (typically 3/4″).
  • Advantages: Pre-kiln-dried to resist warping, free of bugs/mold smells, clean, and often features tongue-and-groove or end-matched edges for fast, DIY-friendly installation. Finishes typically use safe, low-VOC water-based coatings.
  • Cost: Generally, more affordable and budget-predictable than salvaged or reclaimed old lumber and boards.
  • Availability: Available year-round from a retail outlet or online.
  • Sustainability: Made from pine trees harvested from forests or tree farms.
  • Installation: Fast and easy with tongue and groove end-matched boards.
  • Upkeep: Just wipe with a damp cloth or mild cleaner.

Description Of Reclaimed Wood

Reclaimed wood is lumber that is also known as salvaged wood that comes from many sources. It is repurposed for wall paneling, ceiling paneling, flooring, and furniture.

  • Origin: This wood can be any softwood or hardwood sourced directly from old barns, houses, sheds, factories, or historic structures.
  • Character & History: Each board carries a genuine story, featuring unique weathering, original paint traces, deep patina, and natural imperfections.
  • Challenges: Can be scarce, expensive, and time-consuming to source. Boards often require de-nailing, cleaning, bug treatment, and ripping or milling to size due to warping, cupping, or uneven dimensions. Handling raw boards also carries a higher risk of splinters.
  • Cost: Typically higher upfront due to scarcity, labor-intensive salvage, sorting, and custom prep work.
  • Issues: If not properly cleaned, the wood may contain odors, insects, or toxins.
  • Availability: Can be time-consuming to find because it may take several searches to find what you want.
  • Sustainability: Lacks sustainability because the wood may come from hardwood tree species that are not replanted in quantity or not at all.
  • Installation: Can take longer because boards are not typically tongue and groove. Face nailing shows the nail heads. If not properly dried, the boards may cup which makes installation more difficult.
  • Upkeep: May be more difficult to clean if one or more boards expand.
  • Acclimation: Reclaimed wood often needs extra time (often a couple of weeks for flooring) to adjust to your home’s indoor humidity before installation.

“Modern barn wood paneling is manufactured from real pinewood with a unique process to simulate old, reclaimed wood.”

Their Pricing Structures

Knotty Pine Paneling is tongue-n-groove on the sides and end-matched (tongue-n-groove on the ends!) for zero-waste. The typical prices for unfinished paneling are from $2.50 to $5.50 per square foot, depending on width and finish choice. It’s a very affordable way to cover your walls and ceilings with the warmth that natural wood provides.

Authentic reclaimed and salvaged wood for wall paneling typically costs between $7 and $15 per square foot for the material alone. However, the total price can vary widely from $3.25 to over $35 per square foot depending on whether you purchase lightweight DIY kits, premium tongue-and-groove boards, or rare solid hardwood species. There is typically some financial loss due to wasted wood.

For example, a standard 80-square-foot accent wall (8 ft x 10 ft) using reclaimed wood generally costs $800 to $1,200 in materials, including a slight buffer for cutting waste. This costs much more compared to less than $500 for modern barn wood. The price of salvaged paneling heavily depends on how the wood is milled and packaged:

  • DIY Planks & Bundles ($4 to $9 per sq. ft.): These are often thin-profile boards (about 1/4″ to 3/8″ thick) with square edges. These are not as sturdy as modern barn wood.
  • Standard Milled Paneling ($7 to $15 per sq. ft.): These are authentic barn wood planks milled with uniform edges for professional or clean DIY installation.
  • Premium Tongue-and-Groove or Rare Hardwoods ($15 to $35+ per sq. ft.): High-end architectural salvage, custom-milled interlocking panels, and premium species (like antique oak or redwood) command much higher prices due to the labor involved in sourcing, labor, and processing.
  • Waste Allowance (Add 5% to 10%): Because reclaimed boards have natural variations, knots, and unique end cuts, you should always order 5% to 10% more square footage than your wall’s actual dimensions to account for trimming.

Where To Find Modern Barn Wood

The WoodWorkers Shoppe is America’s leading log home material supplier. Our authentic looking barn wood paneling gives you the look of old barn wood siding that has been weathered by the elements for many moons. Now you can have the wonderful decorative look of rustic wood wall or ceiling paneling in the interior of your home without the hassles of using real barn wood. No moldy smells, no strange worms or bugs, no cupping boards, no nail pulling, no sorting, cutting and ripping to get usable pieces. Our barn board paneling is clean, neat and ready to go! Just place and nail. This rustic wood paneling is fast, fun and easy! Our paneling is a Green-Wood Building Product that is Renewable and Recyclable.

This eco-friendly rustic wood paneling has a water base low VOC finish that is safe for you and your home. The barn wood paneling has a smoky dark stain with hazy silver and white undertones that enhances the deep grain of the wood and gives you the wonderful rustic patina look of old barn wood. This rustic paneling will completely change the interior of your home or business.

Weathered Vintage Look

Smooth Surface

 

Don’t like the old weathered reclaimed lumber look?

We also provide our barn siding paneling in raw form for you to stain or if you’d like, our custom finish shop can apply the stain color of your choice! Our barnwood wall paneling is made from 6″ and 8″ pine that is sawn and kiln dried at our own mill. The barn board paneling then goes through a special process that gives the new wood an old look with lots of texture and character. The reclaimed wood paneling for sale here is also tongue and grooved on the sides and ends (available in 8′ random lengths) for continuous application which results in a 15-20% labor savings and up to 20% less material waste!

Resources and References: